Furnace Control Board Buyer's Guide: Rheem vs. Goodman Replacements
When your furnace stops responding to the thermostat, the ignition sequence often fails because the control board is the brain of the HVAC system. The question is whether to pick a specialist Rheem board or a Goodman board that claims compatibility with multiple brands. These four replacement boards range from $60.00 to $199.99, and the right choice depends on the model your furnace needs and how much you want to spend.
Quick Take
Both Goodman boards are listed at $60.00, making them the lower-priced route if your system specifically calls for a PCBCM301 or PCBCM201 board. The two Rheem boards are priced higher-$182.09 and $199.99-but they carry Rheem branding and, in the case of the OEM board, a long list of compatible R802VA furnace models. If you're repairing a Rheem unit and want the exact OEM part, the extra cost buys model specificity. If you're working with a Goodman/Amana/Daikin system and just need the board, the $60.00 Goodman options are the concrete lower-priced path.
Price Comparison
| Product | Listed Price | Price Bar |
|---|---|---|
| Rheem 62-105217-01 | $182.09 | |
| Goodman PCBCM301V0001S | $60.00 | |
| Goodman PCBCM201AA001 | $60.00 | |
| Rheem OEM 62-104061-05 | $199.99 |
The two Rheem boards are about $122 and $140 above the Goodman boards. If price is the decisive factor, the $60.00 boards are straightforward picks. If brand and model fit matter more, the Rheem boards justify the gap through the listed compatibility details.
Decision Matrix
| Product | Price | Best Use | Watch Out |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rheem 62-105217-01 | $182.09 | Rheem furnace repair with a 24V board | Price is far above the Goodman alternatives |
| Goodman PCBCM301V0001S | $60.00 | Goodman/Amana/Daikin systems needing a PCBCM301 V0001 | Ships without original box |
| Goodman PCBCM201AA001 | $60.00 | Amana/Daikin systems needing a PCBCM201AA001 | Also ships without original box |
| Rheem OEM 62-104061-05 | $199.99 | Rheem R802VA furnace owners needing an OEM board | Open-box condition and highest price |
Product Notes
Rheem 62-105217-01 Integrated Furnace Control Board for HVAC Systems
This board costs $182.09 and is listed as New. The description ties it to the Rheem R801TAJM furnace, with a 24-volt rating, which gives you a clear fit signal if that's your furnace. Choose it when you want a brand-new Rheem control board and don't need a long compatibility list. The main limitation is the price: it's the second most expensive option here, roughly $122 above the Goodman boards, so only worth it when the Rheem model fit is essential.
PCBCM301V0001S Goodman Control Board Amana Daikin HVAC Systems PCBCM301 V0001
At $60.00, this Goodman board is one of the two least expensive options in the comparison. It's described as new but arrives without the original box, so plan for that. The model reference PCBCM301 V0001 is specific to Goodman, Amana, and Daikin systems. If your furnace uses this exact board, the low price is the clear draw, while the missing packaging is the trade-off you accept.
PCBCM201AA001 Goodman Control Board Amana Daikin HVAC Systems PCBCM201AA001S
Also listed at $60.00, this Goodman board follows the same pattern: new condition, no original box, and a model number that matters for fit. The description mentions Amana and Daikin systems, making it a sibling to the PCBCM301. Go with this board when your system needs the PCBCM201AA001 board. As with the other Goodman, the box omission is the trade-off, and the price keeps it in the same bracket as the PCBCM301.
Rheem OEM Furnace HVAC Integrated Control Board, 62-104061-05
This is the top-priced board at $199.99. It's listed as New - Open box and as a genuine OEM part, and the description lists a wide range of Rheem R802VA furnace models. For R802VA owners, this is the controller to match with part number 62-104061-05. The limitations are the condition and cost: open-box packaging and a price that runs about $140 above the Goodman boards.
Final Recommendation
If your furnace uses the PCBCM301 or PCBCM201 board, the Goodman replacements at $60.00 are the obvious pick on price. For Rheem owners, the 62-105217-01 board at $182.09 gives you a new board tailored to the R801TAJM furnace. The 62-104061-05 at $199.99 is the one to consider when you want the OEM R802VA compatibility despite the open-box condition. Match the board to your system's model first, and let price break the tie.
